Practitioner Brief

Staff Turnover and Staff Safety in Juvenile Facilities

The Question

When staff leave a juvenile facility, does it change how safe the remaining staff feel at work? Turnover is something every facility director already tracks, and staff who feel unsafe are less able to supervise and support the youth in their care. I wanted to know whether facilities that lose more of their staff also have more staff who say the facility feels unsafe. If the two go together, turnover numbers a director already has could point to safety concerns that a survey only picks up months later.

The Finding

Facilities that lose more of their staff tend to have more staff who say the facility feels unsafe.

Across 85 juvenile facilities, the facilities with the highest staff turnover had about 1 in 4 staff saying the facility felt unsafe. At the facilities with the lowest turnover, it was about 1 in 13. In between, the share of worried staff rose step by step as turnover went up.

Scatter plot: facilities with higher staff turnover have a higher share of staff who say the facility feels unsafe.
Each dot is one facility in one survey period (85 facilities, April and October 2025). The line shows the overall trend.

The pattern is real but moderate: turnover explains only a small part of why some facilities feel less safe to their staff than others. It showed up in both the spring and fall surveys, and it stayed about the same when facilities were compared with others of a similar type, size, and region. Plenty of facilities with low turnover still had staff who felt unsafe, and a few facilities with very high turnover did not.

How I Looked at the Data

I used data from Performance-based Standards (PbS), a national improvement program for juvenile facilities, collected in April and October 2025. Facility reports told me how many staff left in the past six months, which I compared to the size of each facility's current staff. A staff survey told me how each staff member rated the safety of their facility, and I counted the share who chose "unsafe" or "very dangerous," using about 5,000 staff responses. I then matched the two facility by facility and checked whether the pattern held for facilities of different types, sizes, and regions.

What This Can't Tell Us

This finding shows that turnover and staff safety concerns go together. It does not show that one causes the other. Staff may feel unsafe because coworkers are leaving and units are short-handed, but staff may also be leaving because the facility already feels unsafe. Both could also be driven by something this data does not measure, such as leadership, pay, or working conditions.

The safety ratings also come only from staff who were still working at the facility and chose to take the survey. The people who left, who may have felt the least safe, are not in that count. That means the real link could be stronger than what this data shows.

Finally, all 85 facilities chose to take part in PbS. Facilities outside the program may look different.

What Facility Leaders Might Consider

Facility leaders may want to treat rising turnover as an early warning sign for staff safety concerns. A jump in departures could be a good moment to check in with the staff who remain about how safe they feel, rather than waiting for the next survey.

Leaders might also consider asking departing staff whether safety played a role in their decision. Exit conversations would fill the biggest gap in this data, because right now the people most likely to feel unsafe are the ones we never hear from.

This finding does not show that cutting turnover alone will make staff feel safer. It does suggest that turnover and safety are worth watching together, and that a facility seeing a change in one should look closely at the other.